It got me thinking (this is not totally formed) that AI, although a product of a particular set of politics & ethics, cannot show up embodying an ethical and political stance that’s responsive to this cultural/political moment… and thus can not be in solidarity with the people we’re in conversation with…in that way it’s neoliberalism’s perfect agent of social control, a role therapy has a long history of filling.
This is incredibly real written and introduced me to a field I didn't realize AI could have such an impact on, but the way you explained it, it makes total sense. Evidence-based approach to therapy is exactly what AI is designed for, so therapists must adjust their practices to a more personable. Which like you said, implies more creative and relationship driven conversations. I wonder if AI could ever take over the therapy field? My initial belief is no way because AI isn't able in a physical body and creating a real relationship with a person. But would patients even consider going to some sort of AI model or robot (maybe in the future) to discuss their problems? I also wouldn't think so because they wouldn't get the same treatment as with a human being. But then again maybe some individuals would rather not talk to a human and talk to an online chatbot or something technology based. I'm not sure but your blog made me really curious on this topic. I think it's interesting to consider what is going to happen with AI in the future.
Yes, the idea has been used badly, even though it sounded like a good idea. Like many, there are unintended consequences, like so many things we have and do try. If you are going to use a system of algorithm's, you will not need anyone with a brain at all - just trials of one option over another. It is perfect for computers and not for humans. there is an art of any kind of health care, nuanced, personal, relationship-building, rapport, discernment. As you say. Thank you, I think it has been talked about but is lost in all the other noise. It is disturbing, and the same in medicine there is this conundrum. Keep writing!
As always, Chris, this is beautiful— thank you!
It got me thinking (this is not totally formed) that AI, although a product of a particular set of politics & ethics, cannot show up embodying an ethical and political stance that’s responsive to this cultural/political moment… and thus can not be in solidarity with the people we’re in conversation with…in that way it’s neoliberalism’s perfect agent of social control, a role therapy has a long history of filling.
I really appreciate this piece Chris. Thank you for sharing.
This is great and timely information ℹ️ I’ll share with practicum students!!
This is incredibly real written and introduced me to a field I didn't realize AI could have such an impact on, but the way you explained it, it makes total sense. Evidence-based approach to therapy is exactly what AI is designed for, so therapists must adjust their practices to a more personable. Which like you said, implies more creative and relationship driven conversations. I wonder if AI could ever take over the therapy field? My initial belief is no way because AI isn't able in a physical body and creating a real relationship with a person. But would patients even consider going to some sort of AI model or robot (maybe in the future) to discuss their problems? I also wouldn't think so because they wouldn't get the same treatment as with a human being. But then again maybe some individuals would rather not talk to a human and talk to an online chatbot or something technology based. I'm not sure but your blog made me really curious on this topic. I think it's interesting to consider what is going to happen with AI in the future.
Yes, the idea has been used badly, even though it sounded like a good idea. Like many, there are unintended consequences, like so many things we have and do try. If you are going to use a system of algorithm's, you will not need anyone with a brain at all - just trials of one option over another. It is perfect for computers and not for humans. there is an art of any kind of health care, nuanced, personal, relationship-building, rapport, discernment. As you say. Thank you, I think it has been talked about but is lost in all the other noise. It is disturbing, and the same in medicine there is this conundrum. Keep writing!